Recent Posts
NYC Blogs
Click here for a list of NYC blogs
Newsfeeds
Search This Blog

Lining Up on Nonpartisan Elections
July 7th, 2010

Now that its forums on key issues have come to a close, the city charter revision commission will hold a public meeting on Monday at which the members will “discuss the next phase of the commissions work.” While the commission ponders its options about what, if anything, to put before the voters in November, it certainly has plenty of advice it can take — or ignore.

Last week, Citizens Union (whose sister organization publishes Gotham Gazette) weighed in with its recommendations. Amid all the advisers, Citizens Union might have a bit more heft than both, given its long history as a good government group and Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s endorsement in March of the group’s creation of its own charter task force.

Among its 50 recommendations, Citizens Union called for instituting nonpartisan elections, term limits, providing the public advocate and borough presidents with independently funded budgets and giving the Civilian Complaint Review Board the power to prosecute cases.

In backing nonpartisan elections, Citizens Union reversed the stand it took in 2003 when it opposed a proposed charter revision, overwhelmingly rejected by the voters, that would have created open primaries. The mayor backed the idea then — and reportedly still does. Some other civic groups, such as the Women’s City Club, still oppose the idea.

Under the plan believed to be under consideration — and adopted by California voters last month — all voters would cast ballots in a primary open to candidates from all parties. The top two vote getters would then go head-to-head- in a general election.

This system, Citizens Union said in a statement, would “provide that the voice of the 1.5 million voters, who are now effectively shut out from choosing many of the citys elected officials because they are not affiliated with the Democratic Party that effectively determines the vast majority of the citys elected officials in a closed partisan primary, is heard.”

Opponents argue the nonpartisan primaries could be a boost to wealthy self-financed candidates like Bloomberg. Citizens Union endorsed Bloomberg in all three of his mayoral elections.

The proposal also has the enthusiastic backing of the Independence Party, Bloomberg gave $1.2 million to party the last year and — not surprisingly — its endorsement, and line in the mayoral election last year.

At a Democratic Party press conference, last month, Public Advocate Bill de Blasio –a Democrat — was among those condemning the nonpartisan election idea. “Nonpartisan elections undermine our democracy,” he said. “They create a system that is dominated by wealth, suppresses voter turnout and makes it harder for minority candidates to compete.”

About three quarters of U.S/ cities now have nonpartisan elections, according to a study of them by George Mason University law professor David Schleicher. Schleicher told the Wall Street Journal the system has left voters even less informed than they were under the old party-dominated system.

Like it or not, party labels provide information. And so, Schleicher said, nonpartisan elections “take a situation where you know little and reduces it to zero. All evidence shows that voters in nonpartisan election behave as if they have no idea what’s going on and they turn out in far smaller numbers.”

But most accounts the charter commission will put term limits before the voters but predictions vary as to whether nonpartisan elections will make the cut in its draft recommendations, expected in September. The commission — and mayor — have been careful to avoid a replay of the 2003 election when the commission made it clear it would follow Bloomberg’s bidding and put the issue on the ballot before it held even a single hearing.

As to back channels, who knows? After all, as City Hall noted, “most of the staffers … are either current or former city employees, and several split time between the Bloomberg administration payroll and the commission.”

On the other hand, the article said, “Staff and commission members insist that they have had no contact with anyone inside the Bullpen about the mayors preferences.”

By on July 7, 2010, 3:00 pm
In category: City Hall,Electoral Politics,Gotham City,Governing | 3 Comments »

| More

RSS Feed RSS Feed


3 Responses to “Lining Up on Nonpartisan Elections”

  1. Larry Littlefield Says:
    July 7th, 2010 at 9:07 pm

    “Among its 50 recommendations, Citizens Union called for instituting nonpartisan elections, term limits.”

    Better late than never. As I wrote the last time this came up, the way to solve the “party labels as information” problem is to allow candidates to keep their party labels in the general election.

    In one party districts where just about everyone votes Democratic, that would mean a Democrat challenger against a Democrat incumbent on Election Day when everyone shows up. Which is exactly what those who control the incumbents are worried about.

  2. Brigitt Williams Says:
    November 2nd, 2010 at 2:43 am

    The argument goes that will Obama wants to get in touch with a demographic that wouldn’t readily vote in midterm elections except if the candidates performed screeching, off-key tops of Whitney Houston tracks. Wasn’t it just the other day that the media had been slamming Obama for “demeaning” the office of the President of the usa by appearing on the particular Daily Show? I can’t wait to hear what the pearl-clutchers inside the media have to say concerning this latest GOTV effort because of the President.

  3. Jamal Aurges Says:
    August 31st, 2012 at 1:27 pm

    Wanted to let everyone know if you want to fish on Key West’s #1 charterboat call Capt. Allen King.

Leave a Reply

Gotham Gazette the Place for Politics and Policy

Gotham Gazette is published by Citizens Union Foundation and is made possible by support from the Robert Sterling Clark Foundation, the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, the Altman Foundation,the Fund for the City of New York and donors to Citizens Union Foundation. Please consider supporting Citizens Union Foundation's public education programs. Critical early support to Gotham Gazette was provided by the Charles H. Revson Foundation, Rockefeller Brothers Fund and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.

RSS Feed