Piece Of Ireland In Manhattan
From Irish Echo
By Stephen McKinley
In Lower Manhattan, there is a corner of a field that is forever
Ireland. One hundred and 50 years since the Famine, the Irish Hunger
Memorial, a quarter acre of Irish land and stone, opened in Battery
Park City on Tuesday.
Much anticipated in the months before its completion, the finished
memorial stunned onlookers with its scale and its unconventional
commemoration of not just the Irish Famine, but the stark message
that hunger still stalks the world today. Its locationNew
York Cityalso brings to mind those who escaped and found a
new life in the new world.
Around its granite and glass plinth, words that speak of Ireland's
hunger and of current starvation strike the eye and the heart: "Willful
waste makes woeful wantan Irish Proverb" reads one line from
a total of two miles of text.
"Everyday, 25 percent of our food supply is wasted:" the words
of President Clinton in 1998.
And most harrowing, the words of John Costelloe of Galway, from
1847, describing his eviction, were read aloud by Sir Bob Geldoff
at Tuesday's dedication: "He threw my three children out on the
street . . .. "
The sloping field, the abandoned cottage, the useless potato beds
overgrown by grass, clover, heather and rushes are swept on the
western side by the breeze from the Hudson River. On the three other
sides, the memorial is reflected in the glass and polished stone
facades of lower Manhattan's commercial buildings.
It is a scene that allows the visitor to ponder lessons about the
human spirit. Said Mary Daley of the New York State Education Committee,
"You cannot walk in here without having questions to ask."
Addressing the audience, Ireland's president, Mary McAleese, said
that out of great tragedy, good can and will come: "Wherever people
suffer, you will find the Irish bringing hope."
She drew laughter from the crowd while praising the memorial's
artist, Brian Tolle, for his accurate re-creation of the Irish countryside.
"I just don't know who to thank for the very accurate re-creation
of the Irish weather," McAleese said, on what was a cloudless, hot
Because of the Famine and immigration experience, because of determination
and grit, she said, "today Ireland is a first world country with
a third world memory."
As final preparations were made for the dedication, commuters on
their way to work stopped to see the memorial. One Englishman shook
his head in awe, and said, "I had to come to New York to learn anything
about the Irish Famine."
The 69th Regiment provided an honor guard leading the dignitaries
to their places: President McAleese, Gov. George Pataki, Mayor Michael
Bloomberg, former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, and artist Brian Tolle.
Ciaran Sheehan sang the Irish and American national anthems. Paddy
Reilly moved the crowd with his rendition of "The Fields of Athenry."
The chairman of the Battery Park City Authority, Timothy Carey,
presided as master of ceremonies, assisted by Adrian Flannelly,
also a member of the memorial's committee.
Cardinal Edward Egan opened the dedication, reminding listeners
that the memorial was about "the tragedy of man's inhumanity to
his fellow man."
Each speaker sought to remind those present that hunger still afflicts
millions across the world: "Eight hundred million people will go
to bed hungry tonight," said Timothy Carey, before reading a letter
of greeting from President George W. Bush.
Malachy McCourt stood to read one of the lines of text from the
memorial's plinth, and noted, "30,000 children will die today of
starvation . . . " He added, "I call on politicians to stop bombing
people and bring food to them."
Ironically, McCourt's first reading was from early 1840s Ireland,
when an observer noted that potato blight had broken out in America
but that no such thing was likely to occur in Ireland.
Sir Bob Geldoff, founder of the charity the Live Aid Foundation,
told listeners, "I see a lot of what this memorial describes in
Africa, almost every year."
Other speakers noted how the Famine had brought thousands of Irish
immigrants to America's shores, whose many descendants inspired
the world with their heroism on Sept. 11.
"The incredible, strong, indomitable spirit of our police department
and fire department," said former Mayor Giuliani.
"What is important to point out is the close proximity to the site
of the World Trade Center," said Martin McGuinness, the Northern
Ireland Minister for education. "Many of the people who died on
Sept. 11 would have been descendants of people who just managed
to escape the Famine."
During his remarks, Gov. Pataki recalled how he had gradually become
aware of the Famine during his teenage years. He remembered wondering
how the potato crop could fail "year after year, for seven years,"
and how he found out about the effects on Ireland of British policy
at the time.
"This memorial is not to point the finger, but to open eyes about
the Famine and about world hunger," he said.
After the ribbon was cut, guests and the public were allowed to
step through the memorial's rear entrance, or on to the grassy slope
at the front, and spend time reflecting on its complex message.
Martin Rooney, from Longstone, Co. Down, came wrapped in an Irish
flag. "It's very nice to have a piece of Ireland in Manhattan,"
Jim Mooney, an Irish American trader at the New York Mercantile
Exchange next door to the memorial, said: "I watched them build
it for two years. My grandparents from both sides came from Kerry
and Donegal. We've been starved of visitors and tourists down here.
I hope this will bring people down here."
Busy with guests eager to inspect the memorial, artist Brian Tolle
took a moment to run his hand over a portion of the stone wall that
last stood in Attymas, Co. Mayo. "This represents the place, it
represents home," he said simply.
Unnoticed by almost everyone at the memorial, a sparrow perched
watchfully on the cross bar of a street light, just above the first
clump of grass, clover and rushes and the commemorative county stones
for Westmeath and Laois.
The sparrow has a nest in the cross bar, and as an opportunity
arose when there was a lull in the passing crowds, it darted down
into the grass and foraged for food: watching, hopeful and persistent,
adopting to the surprise of green Irish land in New York City, the
sparrow seemed to represent the indomitable human spirit, inextinguishable
even by starvation.
Back to The Citizen page!