Criticism Of Censorship On School Computers
From El Diario
September 19, 2002
Teachers, students and groups committed to the preservation of
civil liberties filed a petition to the Department of Education
on September 18, claiming that electronic censorship filters should
disappear from computers in New Yorks schools.
According to the groups, filters limit freedom of speech and access
to information protected by the constitution.
"In the course of the years we have noted that these filters
restrict access to vital information", said Marjorie Heins,
the head of the Free Expression Policy Project, an organization
committed to the protection of artistic and intellectual rights.
As a result of the federal law act titled the Childrens
Internet Protection Act (CIPA), those schools receiving federal
subsidies in order to enable access to the Internet are obliged
to install filters of censorship on their computers. The act will
be implemented this term.
The problem is that the government contracted private companies
to design the cyber filters and, according to the organizations,
these companies arbitrarily determine what kind of words or web
pages are obscene.
"It is hard to believe that a Catholic orphanage in Honduras
was blocked by these massive filters", said Kevin Bankston,
advocate at the Union for Civil Liberty.
John Elfrank-Dana, teacher of social education in the District
2 in Downtown Manhattan is outraged about the federal school policy.
He stated that in the weeks after 9/11 he found out that the word
"terrorism" had been blocked by the cyber filter at his
About 95 perecent of New Yorks schools make use of a censorship
filter called "I-Gear", that rejects web sites where the
word "anorexia" is mentioned and that even denied access
to the web pages of CNN and The Daily News.
The decision whether to use electronic filters or not in New York
is left with the State Department for Education. A spokesperson
of the institution, Kevin Ortiz, said that the Department "is
obliged to stick to the federal law" and added that if a school
wishes to have access to a special site, it can request admission
by calling the technology department of the State Department for
Translated from Spanish by Kirsten Immendorf
Back to The Citizen Page