the Ices Are Still Italian: Immigration Patterns Shift, Altering
the Old Neighborhood
The New York Times
September 17, 2002, Thursday, Late Edition - Final
Copyright 2002 The New York Times Company
By Joseph Berger
What Sal Calabrese has always loved about Bensonhurst,
Brooklyn, the city's largest Italian neighborhood, is that it provides
the intimacies of a village.
"If I walk out," he said, "I will say hello
to 15 or 20 people and they to me. 'Hi, Sal. How are you? How's
your father?' Like the old days. We're from different places in
Italy, but we live in the same town." But these days, Mr. Calabrese
worries that Bensonhurst may soon lose the congenial feeling that
comes from a place of common habits and pleasures.
Bensonhurst is losing its Italians. According
to the 2000 census, the number of residents of Italian descent is
down to 59,112, little more than half that of two decades ago, and
the departed Italians have been replaced by Chinese and Russian
Mr. Calabrese volunteers that he is part of
that movement. His parents still live in the neighborhood and he
runs a thriving real estate agency there, but three years ago he
moved to Bedminster, N.J., to a 34-acre farm where he breeds Arabian
Italian-Americans, who have given New York City
much of its charm in emblems as telltale as Fiorello La Guardia
and fuhgeddaboutit, are declining sharply in numbers in all the
boroughs except Staten Island. Many New Yorkers worry not only that
they will lose the Italian neighborhoods but that the Italian influence
on the city's personality will fade away.
The census shows that the number of New Yorkers
of Italian descent has fallen below 700,000, compared with more
than one million in 1980 and 839,000 in 1990.
Despite the reputation of immigrant groups for
die-hard allegiance to old neighborhoods, what is happening, sociologists
say, is the continuation of a trend that has been going on for several
decades now: the children who grew up in the working-class and middle-class
homes of immigrant neighborhoods are, like Mr. Calabrese, now professionals,
managers and business people who want suburban homes with backyards
of grass, not concrete.
In Bensonhurst, the Italian-American residents,
who once passed houses on to their own relatives or those of their
neighbors, are selling them to the highest bidders: Chinese moving
up from nearby Sunset Park and Russians moving up from Brighton
And so they are adapting. Mr. Calabrese employs
five Chinese-speaking and six Russian-speaking brokers among his
staff of 40. Salvatore Alba, whose bakery has drawn long lines for
its cannoli and cheesecake since his Sicilian parents opened it
in 1932, has hired a Chinese-American woman to sell Italian ices.
"I figure if they can't speak English, we'll
get someone to speak to them in Chinese," Mr. Alba said of his newer
Still, there are many New Yorkers who lament
the impact that the decline in Italians could have on the city's
character. In politics, for example, Italian enclaves have been
a seedbed for some of the city's most prominent leaders, lately
with names like Giuliani, Cuomo, Ferraro and Vallone.
But Richard Alba, a distinguished professor
of sociology at the State University at Albany, predicts that Italian
politicians will become less common in the five boroughs.
Professor Alba thinks it is telling that Andrew
M. Cuomo did so poorly in his Democratic primary campaign for governor.
He pointed out that with Italians increasingly assimilated and dispersed
and more often voting on issues than on ethnicity, Mr. Cuomo was
unable to ignite a collective ethnic outpouring.
There is, however, a wide difference of opinion
on whether a shrinking Italian population will change the city's
characteristic New Yorkness, Italians having left such a strong
imprint on the city's dialect and gestures, its food and music (think
the "New York, New York" anthem sung by that Italian fellow who
grew up just across the Hudson River), and such stereotypical New
York attitudes as a wariness of authority.
But the writer Gay Talese is not lamenting some
of that passing because many of the signature images of Italians
hark back to a time when Italians, in the public eye, represented
the urban underclass.
"It's not just coming to the port city and finding
an address convenient to the job," Mr. Talese said. "They're carrying
their brains with them to places far from where they work. They're
more mobile because America is mobile."
Still, Mr. Talese, 70, the author of a memoir
and chronicle of Italian immigration, "Unto the Sons" (Alfred A.
Knopf, 1992), volunteers that he still retains much of what he called
the Italian "village mentality." Although he lives in a Manhattan
town house, is married to Nan A. Talese, a prominent book editor,
and is a regular at Elaine's, he visits his 95-year-old mother twice
a week in his hometown, Ocean City, N.J., and takes her to a small
restaurant and then a casino so she can play the slot machines that
give her pleasure.
"I'm still a hometown, small-town guy" he said.
Bensonhurst is a vintage Italian neighborhood,
a place of tidy two-family brick homes adorned with Madonnas in
the front yard and American flags snapping over the front doors.
Its commercial spine, 18th Avenue, is chock-full of pork and pasta
stores and the Italian colors of green, white and red.
Along with Bay Ridge, it was the setting of
much of "Saturday Night Fever," a valentine to the 70's social styles
of young Italians. It also won unwanted national attention when
a black teenager, Yusuf K. Hawkins, was murdered by a group of local
youths in 1989.
It has a long way to go before it becomes what
Jerome Krase, a sociology professor at Brooklyn College, calls an
"ethnic theme park" like Little Italy, where few Italians actually
reside. But its fate seems unavoidable. Its Italians are moving
to New Jersey or Long Island or across the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge
to Staten Island.
On 18th Avenue, the site of the annual Feast
of Santa Rosalia, men still sip espresso in cafes, but there are
fewer men and fewer cafes, and older people have to walk farther
for the Italian products they need.
Chinese novelty stores and beauty parlors are
replacing the cafes. Along the side streets, Chinese, who relish
the neighborhood's orderliness, the schools with seasoned teachers
and the easy subway ride to Chinatown, are buying up the two-family
homes for $400,000 and more.
Aldo Studio, the neighborhood's wedding photographer,
famed for its collection of backdrops like a waterfall, a grand
piano and a white Rolls-Royce, now displays a large photograph of
a Chinese bride and groom standing in front of a maroon Harley-Davidson.
Churches that were once heavily Italian are now offering Masses
In this ferment, many Italians have lost their
"comfort zone," said Jerry Chiappetta, 52, executive director of
the Italian-American Coalition of Organizations, who has lived in
Bensonhurst for 40 years.
"When you have an influx of people who don't
share similar traditions, it's not a question of disliking them,
it's just there is less in common," he said. "And if you're on the
border of should I move or not, it's one more reason to move."
Mr. Calabrese takes it all in stride, as another
turn of the American immigration wheel.
"You go back to the early 1900's, Italians were
moving near the Bowery and you'd have two or three families sharing
a two-bedroom apartment in order to buy a house," he said. "Chinese
are doing the same. They're no different than our people."
There have been few tensions, Italians and Chinese
in the neighborhood said. "Italian people are friendly, easy to
talk to," said Lisa Pan, a Chinese woman who works at her family-owned
business, Wei's Gift Shop, which draws Italian youngsters who prize
its "Yu-Gi-Oh!" Japanese trading cards.
Jeiying Franco, a Chinese woman, who has taught
physics in the neighborhood at Lafayette High School since 1984,
has seen the proportion of Italian students dwindle. "I don't think
Italian people have any resentment toward the Chinese," she said.
"The Chinese are hard-working. They never bother their neighbors."
Mr. Calabrese said that 15 years ago when the
Chinese began to move in, there were complaints from Italian residents.
But with the realization that the Chinese were creating few problems,
all that is left is rueful resignation.
"The feast of Santa Rosalia is still going on,
but how much longer?" Mr. Calabrese said. "If you asked me 15 years
ago, I would have said it was going on forever. Now I don't know,
and that makes me sad because I am Italian."
Back to The Citizen Page