U.S. Policy Leaves Foreign Students In Limbo
Washington Post Foreign Service
Tuesday, September 24, 2002; Page A17
© 2002 The Washington Post Company
By Ellen Nakashima and Alan Sipress
JAKARTA, Indonesia -- It took seven years, but Abdul Malik has
completed his research for a doctorate in social psychology from
the New School University in New York. The Indonesian student is
now set to take the final step, by defending his thesis later this
month. His adviser has agreed to fly in from Paris.
But Malik, an Indonesian citizen, fears he will not make the date.
Though for the past decade he has consistently received permission
to study in the United States, this year he was told to come back
later when he applied for a visa on June 30. Almost three months
later, he is still waiting. His Indonesian wife received her visa
in June and left for New York without him.
Malik is among 10,000 men from 26 predominantly Muslim countries
who are experiencing delays of two months or more as they await
permission to study, work or vacation in the United States, the
result of a quiet tightening of the visa review process in Washington
prompted by the Sept. 11 attacks of a year ago.
There is the group of 52 Indonesian accountants whom Ernst &
Young wanted to send to the United States to be trained in tracking
money-laundering, a crucial element of the war on terrorism. They
did not get their visas in time to go. There are the Whirling Dervishes
of Damascus, a 12-member ensemble from Syria who will not be performing
at an international music festival this month because they could
not get their visas in time. Nor will 30 Indonesian musicians, masters
of the gamelan, a traditional percussion instrument.
They are all men age 16 to 45 from a group of 26 countries with
large Muslim populations, from Indonesia and Malaysia to Egypt and
Turkey to Somalia and Eritrea. Washington has judged that all 26
countries present terrorism concerns. The U.S. government has not
officially released the list.
It is not just ethnic Arab students who are affected. A number
of Malaysian students of Chinese descent have not received visas
in time to return to fall classes in the United States, some of
them at Harvard, Yale and MIT. Malaysia, which traditionally sends
thousands of students stateside, has suffered the largest backlog,
well over 5,000, though in recent days some visa approvals have
begun to come through. Indonesia has a backlog of 2,500 and Egypt
about 800, according to U.S. and other government officials.
The bureaucratic limbo is the latest unintended consequence of
the U.S.-led war on terrorism. Since late June, the number of agencies
that must review each visa application has multiplied, greatly prolonging
the process and swelling the backlog.
"It's a backlog that we have to juggle and keep track of," said
a U.S. government official. "It's not a management problem. It's
an image problem."
Before June, a U.S. embassy could issue a visa if the applicant
qualified and the State Department did not object within 30 days.
Today, embassy officials must have written approval from Washington
for each applicant. Also affected are men who were born in, but
are not citizens of, any of the 26 countries that are subject to
the new scrutiny.
Even U.S. diplomats frustrated with the new policy agree that tougher
border controls are warranted. Many of the Sept. 11 terrorists were
in the United States on student visas. But the policy has complicated
life for thousands of students and created diplomatic headaches
for embassy staff.
Malik, who is staying with relatives in Jakarta, has repeatedly
rebooked his flight to New York. After the fifth time, he gave up.
He checks the embassy Web site every few days for visa announcements.
His visits to the embassy have produced no visa and no explanation
"It is very, very frustrating," said Malik, 42, whose two daughters,
born in the United States, are with his wife. "You want to plan,
but you can't. I'm in limbo, and basically what they told me is
to check. So you check every day hoping that today you will get
it. It is like being trapped in time."
Officials at the New School "have the highest opinion" of Malik,
according to one professor, noting that if the United States were
seeking a student to promote the ideals of tolerance and international
friendship, and who embodies the spirit of moderate Islam -- as
do most of Indonesia's 220 million people -- he would be a model
"It's a personal tragedy and it's a political tragedy," said Richard
J. Bernstein, dean of the faculty of political and social science.
"This is a student we know extremely well. . . . If America is really
serious about its policy of trying to fight terrorism and make friends
among moderates, then this is just the type of student you want
to invite in."
At Pennsylvania State University, about 100 international students
are still awaiting visas for the fall semester that began Aug. 27.
Although the university is allowing them to register late, many
may have to withdraw until next semester or make alternative arrangements,
said Barbara W. Pennypacker, assistant dean of the graduate school.
In the Malaysian capital of Kuala Lumpur, students have demonstrated
at the U.S. Embassy, and some are opting to go to New Zealand or
Australia. Some have written letters to local newspapers decrying
the wait and what they call discrimination against them.
"For the last 40 years, the only really pressing issue with foreign
students was whether they were going to go home when they finished,"
said Donald McCloud, executive director of the Malaysian American
Commission on Educational Exchange in Kuala Lumpur. "Well, now there
are real security issues. When you have a government that never
has had to deal with that, you can't just turn around the next day
and say, 'Okay, we have a system.' "
Exceptions can be made. For instance, if an embassy officer knows
the applicant personally and there is some foreign policy interest
involved, the restriction can be waived. Thus the Indonesian ambassador's
son got a visa to visit his father in the United States. But these
cases are rare.
U.S. government officials say they are sympathetic to the students'
plights, and embassies from Jakarta to Djibouti have issued notices
requesting that applicants apply extra early and expect waits of
two months or longer.
A State Department official said the policy is not meant to target
men because they are Muslim. He said that Muslims from many countries,
such as those in Europe, are not subject to the new rules.
"It causes some inconvenience to some people. But if we are going
to be serious about improving border security, some people are going
to be inconvenienced," he said. He added that U.S. officials are
trying to work out the kinks. "As it happens in the U.S. government
when you have interagency cooperation, it takes time," he said.
"We're trying to streamline and clear the logjam."
Though no deadline has been set for resolving the delays, the official
predicted it would be a matter of weeks, not months.
Back to The Citizen Page