Gotham Gazette

The Place for New York Policy and politics




De Blasio Presents $92.5 Billion Executive Budget with Agency Savings, New Investments & Response to State Shifts

mayor bill de blaso exec bud

(photo: Rob Bennett for the Office of Mayor Bill de Blasio)

Mayor Bill de Blasio released on Thursday a $92.5 billion executive budget for the 2020 fiscal year that begins July 1, an increase of about $300 million from his preliminary proposal in February and nearly $3.4 billion more than the budget adopted last year.

De Blasio’s latest budget plan will become the basis for City Council hearings and negotiations between the administration and the Council before a budget deal is reached in June. The next budget will again mark a record high for city spending, which has increased by about $20 billion since de Blasio took office in 2014.

The executive plan shows results from de Blasio’s first “program to eliminate the gap” agency savings initiative, several new targeted investments, and adjustments based on the new state budget that went into effect April 1.

The administration is not funding many new initiatives this year, with the mayor predicting an era of “fiscal caution” ahead as both the economy and tax revenue growth slow. Most of the increased spending planned for next fiscal year owes to labor contract agreements settled by the administration, which added about $1 billion alone, and hundreds of millions for broad education aid, debt service payments, expanding the 3-K for All early childhood education program, charter school costs, and fringe benefits for city workers.

De Blasio emphasized that the future of the economy remains uncertain and that the last few months have shed little light on what the city can expect both from the national and global economy.

“We at this point are looking at so many contradictory developments, we don’t have a way to make full sense of them, is the truth,” he said. “The volatility of the policy changes in Washington are impossible to trace at this point...Nothing has changed since preliminary. We still are worried and that’s why we kept this very modest.”

The few “strategic investments” outlined in the executive budget include $60 million to retrofit city buildings to cut carbon emissions, $22 million to fund outreach efforts for the 2020 Census, $15 million to expand the “Fly Car” emergency vehicle program in the Bronx, $12 million in baselined funding for services for students in homeless shelters, and $6 million to fund emergency repairs at NYCHA community centers.

The Census funding quickly caught the eye of Council Speaker Corey Johnson, who insisted that the city must provide $40 million for outreach as the Council has requested. That $18 million difference may make one focal point of de Blasio-Council negotiations over the coming months.

In past years, de Blasio has relied on a Citywide Savings Program, calling on agencies to voluntarily identify cuts in spendings through efficiencies and reassessing costs. But this year, the mayor instituted a Program to Eliminate the Gap (PEG) for the first time, following the example of former Mayor Michael Bloomberg, and mandated a $545 million target reduction for a list of agencies to meet. The administration also expanded a hiring freeze which, together with the PEG, was meant to find $750 million in savings across the current and next fiscal year.

De Blasio’s executive budget surpassed that target and includes $916 million in savings, he said; $629 million came from the PEG, including $104 million at the Department of Education. Notably, the administration cut $9 million in planned spending for the ThriveNYC mental health initiative, which is run by First Lady Chirlane McCray and has come under scrutiny in the last few months for a lack of clarity in its budgeting, performance metrics, and results. The City Council had pushed to cut about $50 million from the planned spending on the broad program, which is projected to spend about $241 million in the 2020 fiscal year. 

De Blasio plans to use some found savings to fund $150 million in “additional, unanticipated new needs,” de Blasio said, including $33 million for special education initiatives, hiring school psychologists and speech teachers for needs assessments; $88 million for growing charter school cost mandates; and $35 million to cover a state funding cut for pre-trial mental health evaluations.

The city did manage to avoid some funding cuts and unfunded mandates it expected from the state, but will, according to the mayor, still have to shell out more than $300 million to provide financial assistance to needy families, fund election reforms recently approved by the state, and fill gaps in education funding and health services. The cost is about half the original burden that was estimated at more than $600 million, which had been the de Blasio administration expectation before the state budget was finalized with less pain for the city.

De Blasio said he holds out hope that the $96 million in costs for implementing election reforms -- including early voting and electronic poll books -- could be mitigated. “We’re still hopeful of some state support but nothing is guaranteed at this moment,” he said, forcing the city to account for it in the budget. The state included funding for localities for implementing both measures in the new budget, but those outlays have not been clarified yet.

The executive budget does not add to the city’s reserves but continues to maintain them at the same levels as last year including $1 billion in the general reserve, $250 million in the capital stabilization reserve and $4.47 billion in the Retiree Health Benefits Trust Fund. Comptroller Scott Stringer has urged the administration to increase the reserves so the city has a budget cushion of roughly 15% of total spending, up from the current level of about 11%. The City Council, in its response to the preliminary budget, similarly called for at least $250 million in additional rainy day funds.

In response to de Blasio's executive budget, Council Speaker Johnson, Council Member Daniel Dromm, who chairs the finance committee, and Council Member Vanessa Gibson, who chairs the capital budget subcommittee, issued a joint statement. "The Council is disappointed that Mayor de Blasio has failed to fund many significant citywide Council priorities in the Fiscal 2020 Executive Budget, including many social service programs as well as $250 million in reserves."

They went on to reiterate their demand for more savings and said that "by not funding vital services, the de Blasio Administration is engaging in the same 'budget dance' that it had once pledged to end. This is completely unfair to the nonprofits who run these programs and who are now unable to plan their future."

"The Council will continue to fight for our priorities and programs that make our City stronger," the statement continues. "That includes Fair Student Funding and pay parity for human service providers and early childhood educators," as well as the additional Census outreach funds. "We look forward to the upcoming Executive Budget hearings," they concluded.

The mayor’s executive budget plan for fiscal year 2020 operating expenditures is also accompanied by the capital spending plan. De Blasio’s updated 10-year capital strategy is now expected to cost $116.9 billion, up from $104.1 billion proposed in the preliminary budget. It includes $16.4 billion for school facilities, $13.1 billion for road and bridge repair, $9.7 billion to preserve affordable housing, $8.7 billion to build borough-based jails, and $6.5 billion for maintaining sewer and water infrastructure. De Blasio said the construction of the jails and this the move off Rikers Island was also expected to be completed by 2026, a year earlier than initially projected.

De Blasio did note that the affordable housing component could see an increase once newly appointed Deputy Mayor Vicki Been comes out with recommendations for the mayor’s massive affordable housing program.

“This administration believes in aggressive capital spending,” de Blasio said, though he insisted it’s done with a “watchful eye” on city debt and the broader economic outlook. He noted that the city’s bond rating was recently upgraded by Moody’s Investors Services, a sign of responsible fiscal management, and also emphasized the absence of an infrastructure plan at the federal level.

by Samar Khurshid, senior reporter, Gotham Gazette

Read more by this writer.

New City Civic Engagement Commission Launched

may b deblasio schools

(photo: Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office)

Mayor Bill de Blasio named his eight appointees to a new charter-mandated Civic Engagement Commission on Tuesday, weeks past the April 1 deadline for creating the commission. City Council Speaker Corey Johnson and the Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens borough presidents also announced their appointees while the other two borough presidents have yet to do so.

The 15-member commission was established in the charter through a ballot referendum approved by voters in November, one product of a charter revision commission set up by de Blasio last year. The commission is tasked broadly with increasing involvement in city civic life, and specifically with improving voter access by providing interpreters at polling sites and administering a citywide participatory budgeting program modeled on the system used by the New York City Council.

The commission is expected to hold its first public hearing within the next month and will also go on a listening tour across the city. The mayor allocated $300,000 for the commission for the current fiscal year which ends June 30, and $2.4 million for the next fiscal year, for a staff of seven people.

De Blasio’s slate of appointments, six of whom were chosen through an open application process, according to the mayor’s office, includes activists who advocate for immigrants, people with disabilities, and minorities, and represent a diverse range of nonprofit organizations.

The mayor’s pick for chair and executive director is Dr. Sarah Sayeed, a Bronx resident who has served as senior advisor in the Mayor’s Community Affairs Unit for over three years, working with the Muslim community. The chair of the civic engagement commission is the only full-time, paid member.

“Our democracy begins in communities large and small, where people come together to tackle important issues in our city,” de Blasio said in a statement. “The Civic Engagement Commission will play a crucial role in strengthening this democracy, which is why our appointees have decades of experience elevating the voices of New Yorkers from all walks of life.”

The mayor’s other appointees are:
-Murad Awawdeh, vice president of advocacy at the New York Immigration Coalition and political director for the New York State Immigrant Action Fund.
-Holly Bonner, founder of the parenting blog Blind Motherhood, focused on families with individuals suffering from vision loss
-Amy Breedlove, a business strategist at Urban Quotient and President of the Cobble Hill Association.
-Donna Veronica Gill, a higher education officer at Hunter Bellevue School of Nursing, and advisor to the New York State Youth Leadership Council.
-José Hernandez, president of United Spinal Association’s New York City chapter.
-Linda Lee, executive director of the Korean Community Services of Metropolitan New York, Inc.
-Annetta Seecharran, executive director of Chhaya CDC, a nonprofit focused on housing stability for New York’s South Asian and Indo-Caribbean communities.

City Council Speaker Johnson has two appointees on the commission: Anastasia Somoza, who is the Council’s first-ever liaison to the disability community, and Anthony Harmon, chief of staff for the United Federation of Teachers.

Bronx Borough President Ruben Diaz Jr. appointed Lilliam Perez, vice president of government and community relations at Montefiore Health System.

Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams chose Eve Baron, chair of the Graduate Center for Planning and the Environment in the School of Architecture at the Pratt Institute.

Queens Borough President Melinda Katz's pick was Charles Apelian, vice chair and land use chair of Queens Community Board 7.

Staten Island Borough President James Oddo’s office did not respond to a request for comment. Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer’s spokesperson said they would inquire about the status of their appointment.

The commission members will initially serve staggered terms. Three of the mayor’s appointees -- Gill, Breedlove, and Lee -- will serve for two years while four others -- Awawdeh, Bonner, Hernandez, and Seecharran -- will serve for four years. Each of the borough presidents’ appointees will have three-year terms, and of the City Council’s two appointees one will serve a two-year term and the other a four-year term. Future appointees will serve for four years each.

by Samar Khurshid, senior reporter, Gotham Gazette

Read more by this writer.

Note - This article has been corrected to note that the Queens borough president has also made her appointment. 

Note - This article has been updated with budget numbers for the commission.

Max & Murphy Podcast: The 2019 City Charter Commission Narrows Its Focus

may b d blasio first ferry

(photo: mayor's office)

April 24, 2019 - Max & Murphy Podcast: The 2019 City Charter Commission Narrows Its Focus

The 2019 New York City Charter Revision Commission released its "preliminary staff report" on Tuesday, indicating which areas of city governance and elections the commission will further consider as it prepares to propose changes to voters in November. Gail Benjamin, chair of the 2019 commission, joined the show to discuss the staff report, the commission's work thus far, some of the proposals the commission will consider moving forward, and more. Then, city budget expert Carol Kellermann, former president of Citizens Budget Commission, joined the show to give her analysis of the commission's preliminary report.

Listen to the conversation and let us know what you think -- we're on Twitter @TweetBenMax and @JarrettMurphy. You can listen to the show through the embedded audio below or download the episode wherever you get your podcasts, under "Max & Murphy," and listen to Max & Murphy live on Wednesdays at 5 p.m. on WBAI radio, 99.5FM or wbai.org

by Ben Max, Gotham Gazette

Read more by this writer.

Print Friendly and PDF

Editor's Choice

Gotham Gazette: What's The [Data] Point? 5, with former Deputy Mayor Alicia GlenWhat's The [Data] Point? 5, with former Deputy Mayor Alicia Glen Gotham Gazette: City Council Examines De Blasio's 'New York Works,' Said to Have Produced 3,000 Jobs of 100,000 Goal City Council Examines De Blasio's 'New York Works,' Said to Have Produced 3,000 Jobs of 100,000 Goal Gotham Gazette: City Council Seeks Expanded Power, Sweeping Change in Charter Recommendations City Council Seeks Expanded Power, Sweeping Change in Charter Recommendations Gotham Gazette: The Max & Murphy Podcast The Max & Murphy Podcast