Gotham Gazette

The Place for New York Policy and politics

second-look sentencing

second-look sentencing

  • No One Can See The Future: New York Needs Second-Look Sentencing Before More Lives Are Wasted

    The Court of Appeals (photo: Mike Groll/Governor's Office)


    The past few years have put into stark relief our inability to predict the future. Virologists, epidemiologists, and related medical professionals repeatedly reevaluate their views regarding COVID-19 and its variants. Economists daily revise their opinions about inflation, interest rate hikes, and the likelihood of a recession. Political pundits and pollsters are scurrying to explain why their election prognostications were off the mark. No one can gainsay the limited ability of meteorologists to

    ...
  • For Justice and Decarceration, Enact Second-Look Sentencing

    gov cuomo tours greene correctional fac

    (photo via the Governor's Office)


    Regardless what one thinks of presidential pardons, we should reflect upon a simple truth – convictions and sentences meted out at one point might not be appropriate decades later. That is especially true for many people currently serving life or massive prison sentences.

    Many have argued for sentence commutations for specific classifications of people. In recent years, the Supreme Court has recognized that judges sentencing young people, even for violent crimes, must

    ...