Gotham Gazette

The Place for New York Policy and politics

Citizens Union

City Government

The King of Discretionary Dollars

by Courtney Gross, Jun 25, 2009

Councilmember Lewis Fidler, it's time to take your seat as the council's top earner.

The Brooklyn council member and assistant majority leader sponsored more discretionary dollars in this year's budget than any other member, garnering more than $1.3 million for 83 different programs. While a lot of that funding will go to nonprofits or schools in his Canarsie district, some of it is allocated for youth programs throughout the city.

"I advocate very, very aggressively for youth groups throughout the city and for Brooklyn groups," said Fidler, who chairs the council's Youth Services Committee. "I certainly make no apologizes for bringing taxpayer money back to my district."

Fidler's dollars include $95,000 to the Bergen Beach Youth Organization for senior services; almost $415,000 to the Bergen Basin Community Development Corporation for youth, senior and housing programs; and a $10,000 check for a puppetry program at P.S. 236. These allocations were approved by the City Council last week in a vote of 50 to 1.

In total, the council allocated $48.8 million in discretionary spending -- a slight increase from fiscal year 2009 when the fiscal situation was not as grim, and it spent $48.5 million.

Though Fidler was able to hand out thousands for his favorite programs, others were not so lucky. According to an analysis by Gotham Gazette, council members Tony Avella and Eric Gioia were at the bottom of our list, getting the smallest amount of discretionary dollars at $358,321 each. Gioia was the only member to vote against the budget this year. He did so, he said last week, so there would be more time for members, the public and the media to vet organizations slated for the council's discretionary funding.

In response to his funding allocation, Eric Koch, a Gioia spokesman, said in an e-mail: "Councilman Gioia has been outspoken about his belief that the process for member items leaves too much room for waste, misuse and at times corruption. What's sad is that need and merit aren't the determination for which worthy community organizations get funding. It's a broken system that needs wholesale reform."

Lewis Fidler
Domenic M. Recchia Jr.
James S. Oddo
Leroy G. Comrie Jr.
Inez E. Dickens
Peter F. Vallone, Jr.
David I. Weprin
Joel Rivera
Kenneth Mitchell
Bill de Blasio
Christine C. Quinn
Erik Martin Dilan
Annabel Palma
Thomas White, Jr.
Robert Jackson
Maria del Carmen Arroyo
Vincent Ignizio
Miguel Martinez
James Vacca
David Yassky
Diana Reyna
Maria Baez
Albert Vann
Michael C. Nelson
Melissa Mark Viverito
James Sanders
Jessica A. Lappin
James F. Gennaro
Sara M. Gonzalez
Elizabeth Crowley
Larry B. Seabrook
Kendall Stewart
Melinda R. Katz
Letitia James
Simcha Felder
Helen Sears
G. Oliver Koppell
Darlene Mealy
John C. Liu
Rosie Mendez
Daniel R. Garodnick
Charles Barron
Mathieu Eugene
Vincent Gentile
Gale A. Brewer
Alan Gerson
Helen D. Foster
Julissa Ferreras
Eric Ulrich
Eric N. Gioia
Tony Avella

**This chart shows the amount of funding each member sponsored. It doesn't include funding that was sponsored by more than one member.

These figures include $108,750 for aging programs and $151,714 for youth programs that each council member receives. It does not include items that were sponsored by more than one member.

Every member receives additional funding for what the council calls "local" programming. Much of this funding goes to local nonprofits for programming, from Little League to community theater.

In the past, members have said those close to Council Speaker Christine Quinn receive the most funding, while those who receive far less have a tendency to get on her bad side.

When asked how funding was disseminated, a spokesperson for Quinn, Maria Alvarado, said: “There are various different factors that go into making decisions regarding funding allocations."

For the most part, those who receive the most funding have leadership positions or head up influential committees. For instance, David Weprin, who is chairman of the council's Finance Committee, received $928,321, and Domenic Recchia, who is chair of the Cultural Affairs Committee, got more than $1.2 million in discretionary dollars.

Of the 22 members who voted against term limits, 12 were on the bottom half of our funding list.

Twenty members made a repeat visit to the bottom half of the list, while the top 10 is nearly identical to fiscal year 2009. Three members on the lower half, Eric Ulrich, Julissa Ferreras and Elizabeth Crowley, were all chosen in special elections and have been serving for less than seven months.

Print Friendly and PDF

Editor's Choice

Gotham Gazette: Bratton Assures Manhattan Business Community NYPD Staying Vigilant, Improving Bratton Assures Manhattan Business Community NYPD Staying Vigilant, Improving Gotham Gazette: Sarsour, Brannan on Collision Course to Replace Gentile? Sarsour, Brannan on Collision Course to Replace Gentile? Gotham Gazette: Bronx Program Serves as Inspiration for Mark-Viverito's City-Wide Bail Fund Proposal Bronx Program Serves as Inspiration for Mark-Viverito's City-Wide Bail Fund Proposal


The comments section is provided as a free service to our readers. Gotham Gazette's editors reserve the right to delete any comments. Some reasons why comments might get deleted: inappropriate or offensive content, off-topic remarks or spam.