As befits a conservative crowd, the Republican Party
has not rushed into New York City. The party was founded on July 6,
1854. It will open its first national nominating convention in New York
City on August 30, 2004 — just over a century and a half later.
The GOP says that it is finally coming to New York because we offered
"the best package of goods and services." Almost certainly the proximity
of the convention's dates to the third anniversary of the simultaneous
terrorist attacks on the Pentagon and World Trade Center, and the
courageously aborted attack on Washington D.C., on September 11, 2001
has something to do with it.
The Republican Party does have a long history in
New York. But what has the state done for the national GOP lately? Not
much. To find the most recent Republican presidential victory in New
York State you have to go back 20 years, to the Reagan-Mondale race
of 1984. For a victory in the city, you have to go back even farther â€“
to the 1924 election when city voters supported Calvin Coolidge
The pattern is the same for Congress: declining Republican strength in
New York. At the turn of the 20th century, both United States senators
from New York were Republicans; at the turn of the 21st century, both
were Democrats. In 1904, 20 of 37 New York members of the House of
Representatives were Republican; in 2004, 19 of 29 New York Congress
members were Democrats. Of the 13 members of the U.S. House of
Representatives from the city, only one - Vito Fossella of Staten Island
â€“ is a Republican.
Governor George Pataki is a Republican. So are New York City Mayor
Michael Bloomberg and a majority of the New York State Senate. But the
governor gained office in 1994 not as a result of Republican strength,
but as the beneficiary of an enormous electoral backlash against the
three-term incumbent Democrat, Mario Cuomo. Pataki has held on for two
additional terms through full use of the powers of incumbency, something
that almost all modern New York governors have been able to use to their
advantage. The State Senate remains Republican in the face of a rising
Democratic tide through artful gerrymandering. The Assembly is solidly
The mayor is a Republican by convenience; the GOP was simply a vehicle
for his seeking and gaining office. Bloomberg's unsuccessful effort to
make nominations for citywide office nonpartisan (see related article, "The Short-Lived GOP Revival" by Fred Siegel and Harry Siegel) was just one of many clear indications of his
discomfort with the party label and his desire to free himself of its
The old metaphor used to describe the geography of New York politics was
"the upstate-downstate split." Democrats dominated in New York City;
Republicans ruled (with a few exceptions) to the east, north and west.
But today many rural and suburban districts in the state elect Democrats
to represent them in Congress. Suburban counties like Nassau, Suffolk
and Westchester have Democratic county executives. Democrats have been
gaining enrollment pluralities or virtual parity in many upstate
counties. Statewide, the last year in which New York Republican's voter
enrollment exceeded that for the state's Democrats was 1956. In March of
this year, there were over 2 million more enrolled Democrats than
Republicans in New York State.
And New York is not just a Democratic state, but a liberal Democratic
state. In a recent Quinnipiac University poll, New York voters were more
supportive of affirmative action, more strongly against the death
penalty and more pro-choice than voters surveyed in a national sample.
Ever since the mid-1960s, the national parties have become increasing
divided along ideological lines, with Republicans more conservative and
Democrats more liberal. At the same time, the center of political
gravity in the nation has moved, with the population, to the south and
This has put New York Republicans at a disadvantage. The state's
Republican leaders rose to national prominence when the kinds of
moderate, pragmatic politics and policies that succeeded for them in New
York were those that Republicans thought were necessary to win
nationally. But the ideological polarization of the major parties made
these appeals less attractive to the more conservative national GOP,
while at the same time making the GOP less attractive to New Yorkers.
The failed national career of Nelson Rockefeller tracks the decline of
New York Republicanism as a national force. In 1960, the newly elected
New York governor threatened to take the presidential nomination by
storm. Vice President Richard Nixon met with Rockefeller at the
governor's Fifth Avenue apartment. The two negotiated the famous
"compact of Fifth Avenue". In return for
Rockefeller removing himself from contention, Nixon agreed to various
things Rockefeller wanted in the Republican platform, including, a
stronger position in favor of civil rights. Conservatives responded with
In 1964, Rockefeller was the center of a jeering confrontation at
the national convention as he condemned "extremists [who] feed on fear,
hate and terror, [and have] no program for America and the Republican
Party." The party that year turned decisively rightward and nominated
Barry Goldwater for president. In 1976 Gerald Ford, under conservative
pressure, removed Rockefeller (appointed, not elected, to the post) from
his ticket. No New York Republican has been a serious contender for the
national ticket since.
At the same time, the painful truth is that slow-growing New York has
become increasingly less important in national electoral politics. When
Dwight Eisenhower was nominated in 1952, the state had 45 electoral
votes; this year it will cast just 31. Republican presidential aspirants
may need the campaign money they raise here, but they have shown that
they can win the presidency without New York's electoral votes. And the
kind of appeals that could win a national Republican candidate the votes
of a majority of skeptical New Yorkers might very well lose them GOP
votes elsewhere in the country.
In short, over the last 30 years, national Republicans have learned to
win without New York. If they forgot that lesson - and focused on
winning the state - the positions might well cost them the votes of the
increasingly conservative party faithful elsewhere in the country.
Gerald Benjamin, a political scientist, is dean of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at
SUNY New Paltz and a former Republican elected official.
The comments section is provided as a free service to our readers. Gotham Gazette's editors reserve the right to delete any comments. Some reasons why comments might get deleted: inappropriate or offensive content, off-topic remarks or spam.